Ice Cool Kitty held off late challenges from Scatkey and Borrowing Base to win the $84,325 Montauk Handicap for New York-bred fillies and mares at Aqueduct on Sunday. The 3-5 favorite, Ice Cool Kitty set the pace under Edgar Prado and dug in resolutely to beat Scatkey by a neck with Borrowing Base another neck back in third.